Active · Single Family Residence

540 Hamilton Street

Bellefontaine, OH 43311

$159,900

Listed Aug 21, 2026

Beds3

Baths2

Square feet1,146 sq ft

MLS #226031868

Market opportunity

51 Opportunity Index

Typical for the market based on 6 comparable homes. This is separate from your personal Listing Match.

Price versus comparable homes

neutral

$159,900 versus a comparable median of $159,950 (0.0% below)

Price per square foot

caution

$140 per sq ft versus a comparable median of $129

Recent price movement

positive

11.1% below the original list price

Time on market

caution

74 days versus a comparable median of 8; worth investigating

The Opportunity Index is a research signal, not an appraisal or guarantee. Verify condition, costs, and comparable details before acting.

Listing overview

This Single Family Residence is listed at $159,900 in Bellefontaine, OH 43311. 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, 1,146 sq ft of interior space, 4,792 square feet of land, built in 9999

About this property

INVESTOR SPECIAL - Partially renovated home on Hamilton Street, being sold as-is, where is. Previously 2 bedrooms and 1 bath but in the process of being converted into 3 bed and 2 full baths. Permits were pulled for new electrical service and sub panel, new plumbing, and new hotwater tank. LVP installed on 1st floor. Kitchen cabinets painted and set. New AC unit installed in 2025. Remaining materials on site convey with the sale. Seller will not complete any further work nor make repairs. Agent has ownership interest in the property.

Highlights

Hoa: No
Sewer: Public Sewer
Levels: Two
Basement: Yes
Common Walls: No Common Walls
Water Source: Public
Garage Spaces: 0
Lot Size Acres: 0.11
New Construction: No
Foundation Details: Block, Stone

Location

Nearby schools

What’s nearby

Schedule a showing

Ryan Conway

Broker

Choose a day to see Ryan’s available times for 540 Hamilton Street.

Mortgage partner

Get pre-qualified

See what financing this home could look like with Mike Roman at Highlands Mortgage.

Estimated payment$995/mo

Price: $159,900
Down payment: $31,980 (20%)
Principal & interest: $809/mo
Insurance: $47/mo
Property taxes: $140/mo

Planning estimate using your saved assumptions. Not a quote, pre-approval, or lending decision.

Talk with Mike about this home

Similar homes you may like

Active$159,900

2378 Millerton Street

Columbus, OH 43232

3 bed
1 bath
838 sq ft

Listing courtesy of Eva Hockenberry, Mainstay Brokerage LLC — MLS# 226040899

Active$159,999

150 Chicago Avenue

Columbus, OH 43222

3 bed
2 bath
1,580 sq ft

Listing courtesy of Jeffrey Schultheis, Red 1 Realty — MLS# 226041330

Active$160,000

1321 Lexington Avenue

Springfield, OH 45505

3 bed
1.5 bath
1,344 sq ft

Listing courtesy of Cecilia Hill, Coldwell Banker Heritage — MLS# 226040876

Active$160,000

580 Ward Street

Urbana, OH 43078

3 bed
1 bath
1,488 sq ft

Listing courtesy of Jennifer Coey, Coldwell Banker Heritage — MLS# 226040565

Active$159,000

427 Park Street

Marion, OH 43302

3 bed
2 bath
1,152 sq ft

Listing courtesy of Ryan Meyers, Key Realty — MLS# 226039698

Active$159,000

1037 Warder Street

Springfield, OH 45503

3 bed
2 bath
896 sq ft

Listing courtesy of Stephen Stuthers, e-Merge Real Estate — MLS# 226039949

Listing courtesy of Maleeka Smith, Red 1 Realty — MLS# 226031868. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Listing information is refreshed from the current CCOR feed. Availability, pricing, and details can change without notice.

Information herein is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.